• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Adlex Solicitors

UK internet and domain name lawyers

Call us now: 0207 317 8404   Email us now

Request Callback

We are operating normally during the COVID-19 crisis and are here to help

  • Home
  • What We Do
    • Website and App Terms & Conditions
    • Privacy and GDPR
      • Intro
      • Privacy Policies
      • Cookies and GDPR
    • Contracts
      • Intro
      • Website / App Design and Development Contracts
      • Web Hosting Contracts
      • White Label and Content Distribution Contracts
      • SEO Contracts
      • Internet Affiliate, Advertising and Marketing Contracts
    • Disputes
      • Intro
      • Domain Name Disputes and Cybersquatting
        • Introductory Guide to Domain Name Disputes
        • UDRP
        • Nominet’s DRS
        • Cybersquatting
        • Domain Name Hijacking
        • Domain Name Law
        • Domain Names and Trade Marks / Passing Off
        • Adlex’s Domain Name Legal Expertise
        • Free Legal Opinion
      • Online Copyright Infringement
      • Internet Trade Mark Infringement and Passing Off
    • Content Removal
      • Intro
      • Removal From Google Search Results
      • Removal From Facebook and Other Social Media
      • Removal From Websites
      • Internet Defamation
      • Right to be Forgotten
  • Who We Are
  • Testimonials
  • Blog
  • Contact Us
Home  ›  Internet Content Removal  ›  Helping Google “Forget” – Removing Convictions from the Web

Helping Google “Forget” – Removing Convictions from the Web

Once upon a time, before the Internet was a twinkle in the eye of Tim Berners Lee, the law set up a “rehabilitation of offenders” framework designed to help people convicted of certain less serious offences find work without having to disclose their “spent” convictions, with restrictions around the official availability of such information to employers and others.

And so, in the days when old editions of newspapers quickly wound up as wrappers for fish and chips and you needed Sherlock Holmesian persistence to track down anything a paper reported yesterday or before, many offenders were able to put their convictions behind them and move on with their lives.

No longer. Enter one of the big issues of the Internet era – its infinite memory. Now, as we all know, convictions – and many other kinds of skeletons – are roaming the web in an endless and fruitless search for a closet. And it only takes a few seconds for a Google search to illuminate them with a spotlight.

So what, if anything, can an offender do about online newspaper conviction reports?

In 2014, the European court attempted to balance search engine power with privacy rights by creating a right to be forgotten for “inadequate”, “irrelevant”, “no longer relevant” or “excessive” personal information in EU search results. In 2018, the UK High Court considered how such right to be forgotten principles worked when two businessmen known as “NT1” and “NT2” – for obvious reasons their names were withheld – sought removal of their previous convictions from Google.

Thanks to this judgment, plus some guidance from data protection authorities, we now have more clarity around the criteria which apply to removal of convictions from the web on EU privacy grounds. Of course, as lawyers love saying, every case depends on its own facts. But we can at least identify some key factors which are likely to weigh in favour of removal:

  • a less serious offence
  • a lesser likelihood of repeat offending
  • an older offence
  • if the offender was a minor or otherwise incapacitated in some way at the time
  • if the reporting of the conviction was significantly inaccurate
  • if it’s longer relevant for people to know about the conviction, e.g., an offender convicted of business-related offences has retired
  • if the conviction is “spent” under the rehabilitation of offenders rules
  • remorse and acceptance of guilt by the offender

See here for more information about Google and the EU right to be forgotten

Internet Content Removal · January 5, 2019 · by Adam Taylor

Filed Under: Internet Content Removal

Adam Taylor

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Blog Categories

  • Domain Name Disputes
  • Internet Content Removal
  • Online Terms and Conditions
  • Privacy and GDPR

Twitter

  • Twitter

Recent Blog Posts

  • Moving Services Online to Beat Social Distancing
  • Guidance on Designing your Website / App for Children’s Privacy
  • Helping Google “Forget” – Removing Convictions from the Web
  • 10 Top Tips for Writing a Domain Dispute Complaint

How Adlex Solicitors Can Help You

For a free initial chat, call Adam of Adlex now on 0207 317 8404 or request a callback or email.

  • Home
  • Sitemap
  • Website Terms of Use
  • Privacy and Cookies Policy
  • Complaints

© Adlex Solicitors 2001 - 2022. Authorised and regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority (SRA number 344672).